I've been trying on any character since I read it, at least 4 now,
possibly a miscounted five, and I've always gotten Siegelinde over his
For the first time yesterday though, she said she "Found him and told him
mothers last words", Which is either the first time she's said that to
me, or a lapse in my memory, but when I talked to her again she gave the
usual "I'll just kill him again" line. As I was fuming when I found him
dead again at ash lake, I thought of some things:
1) Is it significant that she said she passed on the last words, and we
shouldn't speak to her again after she says that, (or I'm just forgetful
and she always says that?)
2) Has anyone ever tried explicitly having Siegemeyer kill the last
octopod? So that, in theory, he saved you, instead of you saved him,
that he always seems to say?
3) Has anyone tried using the Princess covenants AoE heal to be doubly
sure that he's above 50% HP and not dieing to the poison of the pit?
As for my most recent try, I fumbled and spoke with him before trying to
save/quit, (he gave the usual saved him line), and when I reloaded he
was still standing there looking asleep. Should I have tried speaking
with him again? Did my delay in quitting, or my failure to just return
to the last bonfire, cause the poison to drop his HP? Looking forward to
either finally getting this first ending of this questline, or just
outright killing all the octopods so I can start getting the ring on some of my
I also find the post about him running back up the stairs before sleeping interesting, I've never seen him do that before.