Rate the avatar above you V3

Can I please ask that you guys actually rate avatars properly (not kawaiii/10 and rubbish like that) and please don't derail. This thread is basically spam as it is and borders on being locked due to that.

If it strays from the purpose more I'm just gonna lock it, you're all just re-rating the same avatars over and over anyway

8/10.

Living up to your name, i see...

10/10

sif & arty/10

9.8/10 

10/10
What are you so shocked about?

What is with the crazy colours/10

Shadowz, please see the request from Serious at the top of the page

9/10.

shadowzninjaz wrote:sif & arty/10

shadowzninjaz wrote:What is with the crazy colours/10

Serious_Much wrote:Can I please ask that you guys actually rate avatars properly (not kawaiii/10 and rubbish like that)

Shadows.. It's not hard. Please don't ruin it for everyone else

Oh i just notice ur comment at the top now serious

7/10

Serious_Much wrote:Can I please ask that you guys actually rate avatars properly (not kawaiii/10 and rubbish like that) and please don't derail. This thread is basically spam as it is and borders on being locked due to that.

If it strays from the purpose more I'm just gonna lock it, you're all just re-rating the same avatars over and over anyway

It might look to you as spam and what not, but we do rate the avatars. It's not always in numbers, but we give our opinion about the avatar itself and react to it. It never said we just have to rate out of 10. And does it matter if we rate the same avatar again? We might want to say something different about it, and the number of people responding on this thread are limited at the moment. 

I'm not mad or anything for the record, I just think this looks like a rather strict and (imo) harsh response. We're constantly talking about the avatars, and giving an opinion is a form of rating too. But do as you please. I just wanted to tell you what I think.


And 9/10 shadowzninjaz, for the blue hair.

Serious is right. It's called rate the avatar. Which means give it a rating out of 10.
If you want to comment on this do it the way it was meant to be done bud.
For example, your avatar.
4/10
Now you comment with your kawaiii or whatever. Also, for the record this is V3 which to me, seems like there are 2 others somewhere. saying kawaiii/10 makes no sense. Especially when I've never heard of the word kawaiii. It's not a strict or harsh remark. It's actually how the thread goes and he's just doing his job by telling you/us the rules.

WaffleGuy wrote:

Serious_Much wrote:Can I please ask that you guys actually rate avatars properly (not kawaiii/10 and rubbish like that) and please don't derail. This thread is basically spam as it is and borders on being locked due to that.

If it strays from the purpose more I'm just gonna lock it, you're all just re-rating the same avatars over and over anyway

It might look to you as spam and what not, but we do rate the avatars. It's not always in numbers, but we give our opinion about the avatar itself and react to it. It never said we just have to rate out of 10. And does it matter if we rate the same avatar again? We might want to say something different about it, and the number of people responding on this thread are limited at the moment. 

I'm not mad or anything for the record, I just think this looks like a rather strict and (imo) harsh response. We're constantly talking about the avatars, and giving an opinion is a form of rating too. But do as you please. I just wanted to tell you what I think.


And 9/10 shadowzninjaz, for the blue hair.

If you look at the OP carphil originally set up, it stated out of 10. Thats how its always been done on here at least, I've been around long enough to know.

I don't mind you wanting to do more than just give a number, but do so as an elaboration rather than replacing your actual rating with *Generic random phrase*/10- because that doesn't mean a thing, it just makes no sense and looks like spam. If you wanna commetn don't just say kawaii/10, because it isn't a rating. Actually say "I think it's kawaii" if you wanna do that. Just don't spout meaningless phrases/10

The comment about rating the same avatars was more to express that this thread is meaningless, so if you don't follow the rules it's not like it deserves to stay open for any kind of forum benefit of pages filled with *response*/10

twigsterxd wrote:Serious is right. It's called rate the avatar. Which means give it a rating out of 10.
If you want to comment on this do it the way it was meant to be done bud.
For example, your avatar.
4/10
Now you comment with your kawaiii or whatever. Also, for the record this is V3 which to me, seems like there are 2 others somewhere. saying kawaiii/10 makes no sense. Especially when I've never heard of the word kawaiii. It's not a strict or harsh remark. It's actually how the thread goes and he's just doing his job by telling you/us the rules.

Rate the avatar does not make it an instant 'out of 10' rating. And I know it's his job, but that doesn't mean people have no options. I'd like to hear his opinion on this. And if this thread gets locked down, then I'd like to know if a 'Comment on your avatar' thread is okay instead. To be honest, it seems like a big deal just because of one word in the topic. 
And kawaii means cute in Japanese, meaning it's a positive reaction to the other guy/girl's avatar.

The Op started the thread that way and NOT rating it properly is derailing. It doesn't bother me when you guys post comments about them. But, not rating out of 10 properly disrespects the OP. And to be honest, there's ALOT of disrespect in this forum lately and it needs to stop. Not pointing fingers at you btw I mean in general.

Waffle- If you look at the OP carphil originally set up, it stated out of 10. Thats how its always been done on here at least, I've been around long enough to know.

I don't mind you wanting to do more than just give a number, but do so as an elaboration rather than replacing your actual rating with *Generic random phrase*/10- because that doesn't mean a thing, it just makes no sense and looks like spam. If you wanna commetn don't just say kawaii/10, because it isn't a rating. Actually say "I think it's kawaii" if you wanna do that. Just don't spout meaningless phrases/10

The comment about rating the same avatars was more to express that this thread is meaningless, so if you don't follow the rules it's not like it deserves to stay open for any kind of forum benefit of pages filled with *response*/10

copied onto this page in case you didn't see.

Serious_Much wrote:
Waffle- If you look at the OP carphil originally set up, it stated out of 10. Thats how its always been done on here at least, I've been around long enough to know.

I don't mind you wanting to do more than just give a number, but do so as an elaboration rather than replacing your actual rating with *Generic random phrase*/10- because that doesn't mean a thing, it just makes no sense and looks like spam. If you wanna commetn don't just say kawaii/10, because it isn't a rating. Actually say "I think it's kawaii" if you wanna do that. Just don't spout meaningless phrases/10

The comment about rating the same avatars was more to express that this thread is meaningless, so if you don't follow the rules it's not like it deserves to stay open for any kind of forum benefit of pages filled with *response*/10

copied onto this page in case you didn't see.

Well, saying kawaii/10 might not mean the same thing to you, but it's not so much different imo.
Alright, I was not around when the OP made the statement then. Is it okay if I make a thread with 'comment on your avatar' instead to get this all over with? I'll make it myself if I get green light from you. I want to avoid this in the future.

Why not, comment on your avatar thread then. Let's do it.

Locked for chronic derailing and spam.