by XuitusTheGreat Sat Sep 01, 2012 2:25 pmsup, I play XBL and wondered if the new greatsword swing speed was all inclusive or just a slower swing for the "fast" greatsword like claymore? do greatswords like the man-serpant greatsword swing the same as before or do they too swing slower? thanks!
+6
nemesismonkey
SnailsAndSlugs
SunlightCrusader
bloodpixel
Fatneckwood
XuitusTheGreat
10 posters
new greatsword swing speed
XuitusTheGreat- Obsessed
- Posts : 335
Reputation : 3
Join date : 2012-06-07
Age : 35
Fatneckwood- Addicted
- Posts : 135
Reputation : 12
Join date : 2012-07-04
Age : 27
Nope. I'm pretty sure all greatsword swing slower in the PTD edition. So no greatsword can really stunlock any more. 
XuitusTheGreat- Obsessed
- Posts : 335
Reputation : 3
Join date : 2012-06-07
Age : 35
not lookin for a stun lock just curious if even the slow great swords got slower >< cause the artorias sword is already slow and if the abyss is even slower then that.... ;.;
bloodpixel- Hollowed
- Posts : 1658
Reputation : 65
Join date : 2012-01-22
Abyss sword? More like, Abysmal sword!
SunlightCrusader- Hollowed
- Posts : 2042
Reputation : 33
Join date : 2012-05-08
Age : 29
Location : Maryland, United States of America
bloodpixel wrote:Abyss sword? More like, Abysmal sword!
:evil:
If you must mock it at least explain. Please. If there is something really bad about it I would like to know.
SnailsAndSlugs- Casual
- Posts : 50
Reputation : 4
Join date : 2012-03-05
Has it been proven that some GS have a slower swing speed than others? I've used them all, and it seems to me like the R1 move set is identical on all of them. In any case, they're all the same speed now, which is slower than they ever were by quite a bit.
nemesismonkey- Casual
- Posts : 60
Reputation : 20
Join date : 2012-03-06
as far as i can tell the swing speed hasn't been touched, its the speed between your second swing that's longer. allowing you to hop out of the stun lock with ease really.
Gaxe- Obsessed
- Posts : 507
Reputation : 6
Join date : 2012-07-21
Location : Steam: TrueDPS
The first hit is normal the second hit is slow.
SnailsAndSlugs- Casual
- Posts : 50
Reputation : 4
Join date : 2012-03-05
Yeah, it's technically the recovery speed that has slowed. They most likely did this to lessen the stunlock capability of GSs. You have to use an ultra-GS or greataxe to get a perma-stun, but then you can only muster 3-4 (2H) swings from a maxed stamina bar.
XuitusTheGreat- Obsessed
- Posts : 335
Reputation : 3
Join date : 2012-06-07
Age : 35
this and the thing said above about 2nd swing are EXACTLY what I was looking for in info thank youGaxe wrote:The first hit is normal the second hit is slow.
oh and for the person wondering why the dude called it abysmal, people be hatin on the str weapons with the new content haha
Gaxe- Obsessed
- Posts : 507
Reputation : 6
Join date : 2012-07-21
Location : Steam: TrueDPS
Why would you hate on str weapons rofl! They are pathetic now. All the dex users got what they wanted :/ -Sigh- I loved using my GS's on the PS3 no one used them anymore. Dex weapons have and always will be a ton more superior than strength weapons which is sad. No matter how skilled you are with GS's it doesn't matter in the end Dex weapons are better.
XuitusTheGreat- Obsessed
- Posts : 335
Reputation : 3
Join date : 2012-06-07
Age : 35
Gaxe wrote:Why would you hate on str weapons rofl! They are pathetic now. All the dex users got what they wanted :/ -Sigh- I loved using my GS's on the PS3 no one used them anymore. Dex weapons have and always will be a ton more superior than strength weapons which is sad. No matter how skilled you are with GS's it doesn't matter in the end Dex weapons are better.
but great swords are more fun :3 ( to me) theres something just dull to poking weapons idk haha
Gaxe- Obsessed
- Posts : 507
Reputation : 6
Join date : 2012-07-21
Location : Steam: TrueDPS
I love UGS but still it's sad how dex wepaons are better.
Phoenix Rising- Caffeinated
- Posts : 892
Reputation : 29
Join date : 2012-05-04
Age : 46
SunlightCrusader wrote:bloodpixel wrote:Abyss sword? More like, Abysmal sword!
:evil:
If you must mock it at least explain. Please. If there is something really bad about it I would like to know.
He's not mocking it trust me. He has an Abyss Sword fetish...
Noob-of-Artorias- Insomniac
- Posts : 1075
Reputation : 63
Join date : 2012-04-29
Age : 32
Location : San Diego
Greatswords will always be #1 in my heart, I don't care if they nerfed my MLGS into the ground, it'll always be amazing in my eyes!
Rifter7- Hollowed
- Posts : 1523
Reputation : 69
Join date : 2012-05-05
Location : Tama
good i hate stunlocking with greatswords and i use them.
besides, you can still 2h r1-r2 combo with the claymore so who gives a s***. the mlgs has it's awesome r2's still too, and everyone's poise is going to be garbage after the patch hits so this makes sense.
just don't rely on r1 spam as much anymore and focus on your combos instead.
besides, you can still 2h r1-r2 combo with the claymore so who gives a s***. the mlgs has it's awesome r2's still too, and everyone's poise is going to be garbage after the patch hits so this makes sense.
just don't rely on r1 spam as much anymore and focus on your combos instead.
SunlightCrusader- Hollowed
- Posts : 2042
Reputation : 33
Join date : 2012-05-08
Age : 29
Location : Maryland, United States of America
Phoenix Rising wrote:SunlightCrusader wrote:bloodpixel wrote:Abyss sword? More like, Abysmal sword!
:evil:
If you must mock it at least explain. Please. If there is something really bad about it I would like to know.
He's not mocking it trust me. He has an Abyss Sword fetish...
Oh I guess he is using the much less common definition of abysmal then. Thats different.
Last edited by SunlightCrusader on Sun Sep 02, 2012 2:48 pm; edited 1 time in total
SnailsAndSlugs- Casual
- Posts : 50
Reputation : 4
Join date : 2012-03-05
I did quite a bit of PvP last night on PC, enough to earn 50 humanity, mostly at kiln. I was SL-85, darkwraithing and also getting invaded a lot by Darkmoon and Darkwraith. Here are some observations relating to greatswords:
-People generally have less poise now (due to DWGR nerf)
-^ only wolf ring users seem to have high enough poise to resist stun from a GS or curved GS
-GS users seem to be playing 1-handed more often than they used to, and due to most opponenets having lower poise, they seem to be trying to stunlock with 1H R1 attacks now since the speed 1H wasn't nerfed
-I tried out a Gravelord GS for a while with excellent results. Most people stunned on 1st or 2nd hit
It seems the new essential poise breaking point is 36 instead of 53 in order to resist 1H GS stunlock. People still want to fast roll and aren't as afraid of GSs. Going 2H with a curved GS gives an advantage against players with this mentality. Of course, katanas are still extremely popular and effective with an even faster combo speed. (I swear the chaos blade has more weight in terms of poise-breaking than the other katanas). I think I'm gonna take off my RoFaP and equip havel's + wolf for better poise. With havel's + RoFaP, I still can't get up to 53 poise at <25% equip.
Anyway, those are my observations on GS viability in the evolving meta-game. I didn't see very many GS users at all last night. Only a few. I saw mostly silver tracer crit fishers and katana users. Only one other guy was using the gravelord GS, but I can predict they will become much more popular as SL99-120 pvp heats up on PCs.
-People generally have less poise now (due to DWGR nerf)
-^ only wolf ring users seem to have high enough poise to resist stun from a GS or curved GS
-GS users seem to be playing 1-handed more often than they used to, and due to most opponenets having lower poise, they seem to be trying to stunlock with 1H R1 attacks now since the speed 1H wasn't nerfed
-I tried out a Gravelord GS for a while with excellent results. Most people stunned on 1st or 2nd hit
It seems the new essential poise breaking point is 36 instead of 53 in order to resist 1H GS stunlock. People still want to fast roll and aren't as afraid of GSs. Going 2H with a curved GS gives an advantage against players with this mentality. Of course, katanas are still extremely popular and effective with an even faster combo speed. (I swear the chaos blade has more weight in terms of poise-breaking than the other katanas). I think I'm gonna take off my RoFaP and equip havel's + wolf for better poise. With havel's + RoFaP, I still can't get up to 53 poise at <25% equip.
Anyway, those are my observations on GS viability in the evolving meta-game. I didn't see very many GS users at all last night. Only a few. I saw mostly silver tracer crit fishers and katana users. Only one other guy was using the gravelord GS, but I can predict they will become much more popular as SL99-120 pvp heats up on PCs.
|
|
|
