Ultimate Lordran Tournament 2/1-2/3

The battle between Sieglinde of Catarina and Oscar of Astora





Link to Main Thread

Sieglinde gives you a slab, but Oscar gives you estus. Tough call.

You can go through the game without a slab no problem. Lets see you try to get through it without estus.

It wouldn't be so bad if you could farm an estus flask from one of those undead soldiers. Unless they make the drop rate comparable to the slab drop rate from darkwraiths.

I was gonna say Sieglinde because she reaches Ash Lake with no issue, while Oscar is supposed to be lower level but then I remembered we are assuming same sl.

With that in mind I feel they're evenly matched. I don't recall allowing her a chance to heal so I don't know if she can. Oscar obviously can so I give him an edge. Furthermore, even if she can too he would have the easier time punishing a heal with better weapon speed.

Oscar but barely

Oscar is a badass, he reaches a lot of places on his own too. You can see his messages all over the place. My bet is on that blue devil that fell through the ceiling

Yeah. That's why I called it even. They're both pretty accomplished.

Oscar has slain every boss up to and including Orstein and Smough. Oscar all the way!

Hmm tough one. I'd say Sieglind since its more dificult to kill her than Oscar, and she can gank you with Siegmeyer. She don't use any magic so Crest shield is useless, and a Bastards sword will definitely do more damage than the Astora sword.

Lore wise, dunno, they're pretty balanced.

Sieglinde's voice gives you ear massage so obviously Lin takes this one

Carphil wrote:Hmm tough one. I'd say Sieglind since its more dificult to kill her than Oscar, and she can gank you with Siegmeyer. She don't use any magic so Crest shield is useless, and a Bastards sword will definitely do more damage than the Astora sword.

Lore wise, dunno, they're pretty balanced.

If it's just a straight up one on one match between Sieglind and Oscar I'd say it's a flip of a coin, but if it's a team match... Well don't forget that Oscar had been teamed with Tarkus during his travels. So true that Sieglind and Siegmeyer could gank Oscar, it would only be right that Tarkus be the one to even the odds... or completely reck the odds considering how Tarkus just seems to wreck everything that's in his path.

Oh lord no. Someone better break this tie before the day ends.

Whoa a tie! Now I'm very curious to see who will win

Oscar, the OG of Astora

First off this idea is awesome.

Hmmm...

I think she wins the poise exchange stunlock battle thing, even if they are NPCs.

Then there's the whole I killed my father bada$$ factor.

Also Astora seems kinda dumb to me. Why throw the whole body down there? Why not just the key? And last time I checked, the flask he gave me was full. Was he just tired of it all or something?

Then theres also how she gets all "David Blaine" and holds her breath for Lord knows how long inside that golem..... :Baal01:

I say a chick who knows what to do with a big sword should get my vote.

It's pretty close, I'll give it to Oscar just cause he can parry though.