by befowler Thu Feb 16, 2012 8:46 pm
I played Demon Souls 2+ years ago and got maybe halfway before stopping (was offline 'cause no internet at the time). After playing a lot of Dark Souls, I went back and recently beat Demon Souls on NG. It was a lot of fun actually, and I think it is a much harder game than DkS. Certainly the vibe is much darker, which is part of it.
Online play is obviously slow, and I only saw a few signs the entire game. I did get summoned maybe 10-12 times though (levels 35-40 and 60 seemed to be hotspots in 2-2 and 1-3+/4-2 respectively), plus got invaded a few times here and there noticeably 4-1, 4-2 etc. One interestingly thing is that char builds seemed to matter more in DS -- I did a classic faith build with holy mirdan + adjudicators + old king armor for all the regen and had no problem with invaders even though I had no idea how to PvP. The great build more than made up for my play deficiencies, which is rarely the case in DkS.
All in all, I like Dark Souls because coop is more fun there, but think Demon Souls has better atmosphere and style, and generally better level design. I'm prouder of beating demon souls than I am of dark souls for sure