wep damage comparsion

hey guys i need a reference to a good calculator as i cannot find one that is calibrated since the new patch changing scaling... which would be a better butcher knife with 30 str, 10 humainty?

+15 butcher
chaos+5 butcher
light +5 butcher

http://mugenmonkey.com/darksouls/

It is said that non elemental weapons are better AR and better for pvp.

I would go lightning though, it slaughters pve and I like lightning in games lol

That calc doesnt put humanity in for chaos Just something to be aware of

It does, put 10 humanity in the humanity thing and you'll see the AR increase.

going higher than 10 will not bring your chaos up anymore for this reason alone. pvpers who use chaos will get stronger with every win and will one day be almost unstoppable at 99 humainty

Yeah I know it stops at 10
also the smart ones would farm it up before hand although the idea of getting stronger with each kill in pvp appeals to me

+15 will almost always out damage its elemental counterparts. This is because of split damage. The higher the split damage, the more reduction % is done. IMO, the only advantage of elemental weapons is it allows you to put more points into other stats and less into Str and Dex.