Mr. Tart wrote:I'm just gonna go with a long shot. Could it in any way have anything to do with Sif and Artorias?
Edit: Le guess: Artorias sword, which is later on held by Sif.
This guess needs clarification.
Is it the
Greatsword of Artorias or the
Greatsword of Artorias (cursed)?
Secondly, the Golem itself is outside the category parameters.
Rynn clearly gives "weapon" as a category:
2) A riddle submitted must contain a category. They are as follows:
-
Items: This includes all the items in the game, as well as the keys. ie green blossom, peculiar doll, bequethed lord soul, weapon smith box, etc.
-
People: Any person directly in game, or hinted to in lore. This would also include enemies, bosses, optional bosses, etc.
-
Weapons: This includes weapons, armor, shields, ammunition, spells, pyros, miracles, and rings.
-
Misc: This includes anyhting outside of the other categories.
Using the categories outside of explicitly stating which category your riddle falls into is a clear violation of the rules.
If Rynn's riddle does not fall under the "weapon" category, I will allow her to clarify.
This is a one time deal to clear up confusion. If at any time a riddle is submitted with the intention of deceiving the guessers regarding a category, the riddle will be excluded and removed from the competition. I'm not saying Rynn has done this, but this needs clarified. For future reference.
There's also a chance a riddle could be accidentally placed into the wrong category by the author. For instance the "misc" could be mistaken for something that clearly should have been placed in the "people" category.
This will surely be reflected in the "riddle off" poll, as I'm sure guessers would not appreciate being intentionally decieved by the author regarding something as simple as a category.
So now, Rynn, if you could please verify your category, we can move on.
Thanks in advance.
by Rynn Fri Mar 15, 2013 12:05 pm
