Is Dark Souls your favorite game of all time?

RantFromRant wrote:

Forum Pirate wrote:As an avid FF fan, I have long since declared kingdom hearts herasy. I think the last straw was like 40 min in. "Leon". Wrong wrong wrong wrong wrong.

I did however beat the first one, gave it a fair shake. The gameplay was fine, it was the misrepresentation of established Final Fantasy characters that got to me.

Same reason i dont watch movies based on books i've read.

the book to movie thing sometimes sucks which is why im so pissed right now with a game of throes, season one was actually really good and they did an awesome job but season two sucks so bad i dont even know. WHERE IS MEERA AND JOJEN HBO?!!! WHERE?!!!

One word: Congo

Forum Pirate wrote:Liking the FF8 love, good to know I'm not alone there.

Anyways top 10?

0)Legend of Dragoon

1)Skies of Arcadia

1)Star Ocean Till the End of Time

2)Final Fantasy 8

3)Legend of Legia (nostalgia goggles may be a factor here)

5)Final Fantasy 7

6) Elder scrolls 3: Morrowind

7) Elder Scrolls 5: Skyrim

8)Star wars: Knights of the Old Republic

9)Mass Effect 1

Fixed that for you.

well, here goes, in no order:

Megaman 2
Dr Chaos
Strider
Sonic 2, 3, &knuckles
DnD Warriors of the Eternal Sun
Dune
Xmen 1
Twisted Metal 1, 2
Final Fantasy 7, 8
Final Fantasy Tactics
Metal Gear Solid
Lunar: Silver Star Story Complete
Final Doom
Kings Field 1, 2
Resident Evil 1-4
Castlevania 2, Symphony of the Night
Bushido Blade
Legend of Legia
Legend of Dragoon
Shadow of the Colossus
Darksiders
Baldurs Gate 2(pc)
Unreal Tournament(first one on pc)
Diablo 1, 2
Demons/Dark Souls

annnnd many more, im just tired of typing this on my phone lol

He's heating up......Hes on FIRE! Best game ever

Yeah, only one I continue to play after getting the platinum trophy.

The Legend of Zelda: Ocarina of Time
Kingdom Hearts
Pokemon Red Version

ooo forgot that even though it was on my mind...pokemon red/silver

mugenis4real wrote:The Legend of Zelda: Ocarina of Time
Kingdom Hearts
Pokemon Red Version

KH! WHOO! 1 or 2?

Imarreteet23 wrote:It seems like quite a few people here have Shadow of the Colossus on their list. Just wondering, what is your reason? For me, I really liked both the story, and the gameplay. Something that is rare amongst most video games. I just loved the gameplay because of the whole factor of "Holy crap, I just took down that gigantic hulk of a creature with just my puny little sword. Awww yeeahh." And I liked the story because:

Spoiler:

I liked SotC a lot, no question. But I was annoyed by its controlls which are way to inaccurate. Although I like the idea of minimalism, the world seemed to empty, which is the same (but even worse) for ICO.


I can not give any list of favorite games, but I always like athmosphere and "grief-elemets"... e.g. I played "D" as a kid on my loved SEGA SATURN and I was mindblown...sure, today it looks crappy, but back than I was totally sucked in by its strange atmosphere.

I also loved NIGHTS (SATURN), TOMB RAIDER 1 (SATURN), SHADOW MAN (PC), GOTHIC 2 (PC)...

but for sure, DARK SOULS made a maniac out of me lately...

ahhh Tomb Raider...the TRex for the first time was great, soooo many games that have ate sooo many hours, especially if youve gamed as long as I have.

Klosi, that mask is ****ing terrifying.

yes, the T-Rex was awesome !

@Quarik

Thank you, but its not mine, I just found the picture in that crazy internets!

JoeBroski09 wrote:

mugenis4real wrote:The Legend of Zelda: Ocarina of Time
Kingdom Hearts
Pokemon Red Version

KH! WHOO! 1 or 2?

Ahhhhh! Please don't make me pick :bom:

mugenis4real wrote:

JoeBroski09 wrote:

mugenis4real wrote:The Legend of Zelda: Ocarina of Time
Kingdom Hearts
Pokemon Red Version

KH! WHOO! 1 or 2?

Ahhhhh! Please don't make me pick :bom:

Two just simply has better everything, though! It may not have as many extras, but the initial game playthrough is just soooo goood! Amazing story, amazing gameplay! What else can you ask for?

I'll have to say that Dark Souls is indeed my favourite game. I've never put so many hours into a game before. Demon's Souls is also one of my favourites.

JoeBroski09 wrote:

mugenis4real wrote:

JoeBroski09 wrote:

mugenis4real wrote:The Legend of Zelda: Ocarina of Time
Kingdom Hearts
Pokemon Red Version

KH! WHOO! 1 or 2?

Ahhhhh! Please don't make me pick :bom:

Two just simply has better everything, though! It may not have as many extras, but the initial game playthrough is just soooo goood! Amazing story, amazing gameplay! What else can you ask for?

Amazing music?

They both have heart tearing music. Ive cried to both endings of 1 and 2

And the intros, though that was nostaligia after beating both games, i went back. I dont usually cry, but kh touches me hardcore

#1 LOK series loved those games
#2 FF VI VII VII IX X
#3 Souls series
all other games are ok but those are the games i can pick up and play again at any point

Legend of Zelda Ocarina of time was my favorite till I found dark souls which felt like a super version of it.

Noob-of-Artorias wrote:
1. The Legend of Zelda: Majora's Mask - Oh I'm sorry, were you expecting a different Zelda game here? Well tough luck, Majora's Mask is not only one of the most memorable games I've played, it's also one of the most finely polished, everything that made Ocarina great is here in spades plus more.

Have to agree with you on this one 100%