by Dibsville Fri May 31, 2013 6:29 pmIf he was truly omnipotent, then he would be able to create something that he could not lift, as he would have the power to do so.
+6
Soris Ice Goldwing
Tolvo
Encore
Serious_Much
Elifia
Dibsville
10 posters
Philosophy Time
Dibsville- Abyss Dweller
- Posts : 9377
Reputation : 134
Join date : 2013-03-09
Age : 26
Location : Gensōkyō
Serious_Much- Moderator Trainee
- Posts : 14641
Reputation : 287
Join date : 2012-01-17
Age : 31
Location : The Dark Side of the Moon
Tolvo wrote:The version of himself he is imagining does not have to be omnipotent.
But then if he cannot imagine a a boulder that he can't lift when he's all powerful.. doesnt that mean he's not omniscient (all knowing)
Serious_Much- Moderator Trainee
- Posts : 14641
Reputation : 287
Join date : 2012-01-17
Age : 31
Location : The Dark Side of the Moon
Dibsville wrote:If he was truly omnipotent, then he would be able to create something that he could not lift, as he would have the power to do so.
No dibs, that's impossible. think about it. If you're all powerful. How could you create something someone who is all powerful can't lift? It's impossible
Dibsville- Abyss Dweller
- Posts : 9377
Reputation : 134
Join date : 2013-03-09
Age : 26
Location : Gensōkyō
If he was really both omnipotent and omniscient, he would have both the power and knowledge to make something even higher than him.
Tolvo- Town Crier
- Posts : 13287
Reputation : 542
Join date : 2012-02-01
Age : 31
Location : The Forest, Illinois
I study philosophy, religions, and I'm frequently coming up with hypothetical situations. See if you can keep up Serious. 
It may just mean that it is all knowing, just that the only possible way for it to have a boulder it cannot lift is if it is not omnipotent.
It's just like, "Can god make a boulder he can't lift?" Yes, easily, he can create a boulder then remove his omnipotence.
It may just mean that it is all knowing, just that the only possible way for it to have a boulder it cannot lift is if it is not omnipotent.
It's just like, "Can god make a boulder he can't lift?" Yes, easily, he can create a boulder then remove his omnipotence.
Serious_Much- Moderator Trainee
- Posts : 14641
Reputation : 287
Join date : 2012-01-17
Age : 31
Location : The Dark Side of the Moon
Anyways I need to get back to work, but this is the wiki page on that question:
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Omnipotence_paradox
It's basically an endless discussion that can't really be solved (mainly since we don't actually know god's limit (if he exists) )
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Omnipotence_paradox
It's basically an endless discussion that can't really be solved (mainly since we don't actually know god's limit (if he exists) )
Dibsville- Abyss Dweller
- Posts : 9377
Reputation : 134
Join date : 2013-03-09
Age : 26
Location : Gensōkyō
But he would still be able to lift the boulder, because he could return his power in order to lift it. In a way, the answer could be both yes and no.Tolvo wrote:I study philosophy, religions, and I'm frequently coming up with hypothetical situations. See if you can keep up Serious.
It may just mean that it is all knowing, just that the only possible way for it to have a boulder it cannot lift is if it is not omnipotent.
It's just like, "Can god make a boulder he can't lift?" Yes, easily, he can create a boulder then remove his omnipotence.
Tolvo- Town Crier
- Posts : 13287
Reputation : 542
Join date : 2012-02-01
Age : 31
Location : The Forest, Illinois
No, if he removed his omnipotence he is no longer omnipotent, so he simply can make himself be omnipotent again. The boulder was made by an omnipotent being, and god would no longer be able to return to his former power. He would then be the second strongest thing in existence, with the boulder's mass being the strongest.
Now without removing his omnipotence, yes it is a paradox.
Now without removing his omnipotence, yes it is a paradox.
Dibsville- Abyss Dweller
- Posts : 9377
Reputation : 134
Join date : 2013-03-09
Age : 26
Location : Gensōkyō
But by removing his omnipotence, then the boulder now being the omnipotent one could never be lifted, unless his omnipotence was returned. As he is omniscient, he would have the knowledge to return his omnipotence, but as the boulder is the new omnipotent being, he would both no longer be omnipotent yet could still lift the boulder.
KrazykevS10- Hollowed
- Posts : 1566
Reputation : 36
Join date : 2013-01-28
Age : 31
Location : Ireland
The answer is 42.
Tolvo- Town Crier
- Posts : 13287
Reputation : 542
Join date : 2012-02-01
Age : 31
Location : The Forest, Illinois
Just because you know how to do something doesn't mean you can do it. Just like a person without legs, he may know how to become omnipotent again but the only way how may require omnipotence in the first place.
Encore- Chosen Undead
- Posts : 4317
Reputation : 28
Join date : 2013-05-12
Age : 26
Location : Bracing myself for the Winds of Change, being supported by the towering pillars of my friends.
How did you reach the conclusion that the boulder is omnipotent?
Dibsville- Abyss Dweller
- Posts : 9377
Reputation : 134
Join date : 2013-03-09
Age : 26
Location : Gensōkyō
Like I just said, he may know how to obtain his omnipotence of before, but he will no longer be omnipotent.
It's a paradox, 2 sides to the coin.
But then, what happens if the coin lands in the middle?
Will he both re-obtain his omnipotence yet still not be able to lift the boulder?
It's a paradox, 2 sides to the coin.
But then, what happens if the coin lands in the middle?
Will he both re-obtain his omnipotence yet still not be able to lift the boulder?
Dibsville- Abyss Dweller
- Posts : 9377
Reputation : 134
Join date : 2013-03-09
Age : 26
Location : Gensōkyō
If God created a boulder of extraordinary power, then removed his omnipotence, then the boulder would now be omnipotent, not God.Tehdoomgrasp wrote:How did you reach the conclusion that the boulder is omnipotent?
Tolvo- Town Crier
- Posts : 13287
Reputation : 542
Join date : 2012-02-01
Age : 31
Location : The Forest, Illinois
Dibs what I just stated isn't a paradox, it's quite logical actually. Please don't throw words around that you do not understand.
Serious_Much- Moderator Trainee
- Posts : 14641
Reputation : 287
Join date : 2012-01-17
Age : 31
Location : The Dark Side of the Moon
Dibsville wrote:If God created a boulder of extraordinary power, then removed his omnipotence, then the boulder would now be omnipotent, not God.Tehdoomgrasp wrote:How did you reach the conclusion that the boulder is omnipotent?
A boulder can't be omnipotent... it's a rock. It can't create worlds and make life lol
oh and the question itself is a paradox, for example dibs.
Dibsville- Abyss Dweller
- Posts : 9377
Reputation : 134
Join date : 2013-03-09
Age : 26
Location : Gensōkyō
That would depend on how God created it. He could give it life, an imagination, its own being.Serious_Much wrote:Dibsville wrote:If God created a boulder of extraordinary power, then removed his omnipotence, then the boulder would now be omnipotent, not God.Tehdoomgrasp wrote:How did you reach the conclusion that the boulder is omnipotent?
A boulder can't be omnipotent... it's a rock. It can't create worlds and make life lol
Serious_Much- Moderator Trainee
- Posts : 14641
Reputation : 287
Join date : 2012-01-17
Age : 31
Location : The Dark Side of the Moon
Then by definition it wouldn't be a rock anymore.. it would be a golem right? that's what a living rock is?
But yeah, its a rock, not an omnipotent being.
But yeah, its a rock, not an omnipotent being.
Dibsville- Abyss Dweller
- Posts : 9377
Reputation : 134
Join date : 2013-03-09
Age : 26
Location : Gensōkyō
By Spongebob's definition, a rock and a boulder are two different things.
It was never a rock to begin with...
It was never a rock to begin with...
Tolvo- Town Crier
- Posts : 13287
Reputation : 542
Join date : 2012-02-01
Age : 31
Location : The Forest, Illinois
A boulder is a type of rock Dibs.
And yes it would be a golem, or a construct.
And yes it would be a golem, or a construct.
Dibsville- Abyss Dweller
- Posts : 9377
Reputation : 134
Join date : 2013-03-09
Age : 26
Location : Gensōkyō
But God would have the power to make it stay as a boulder, being the all-powerful being that he is.
Tolvo- Town Crier
- Posts : 13287
Reputation : 542
Join date : 2012-02-01
Age : 31
Location : The Forest, Illinois
It would not be a boulder anymore Dibs.
Dibsville- Abyss Dweller
- Posts : 9377
Reputation : 134
Join date : 2013-03-09
Age : 26
Location : Gensōkyō
Why?
If he was all-powerful, he could make anything a boulder, no matter what it was.
If he was all-powerful, he could make anything a boulder, no matter what it was.
Serious_Much- Moderator Trainee
- Posts : 14641
Reputation : 287
Join date : 2012-01-17
Age : 31
Location : The Dark Side of the Moon
Dibsville wrote:But God would have the power to make it stay as a boulder, being the all-powerful being that he is.
There's a reason god called everything different names- so we could differentiate things
By all means he could have created everything and called it all 'boulder'. But he didn't, and hence, a boulder is just a boulder
What you're proposing is a paradox there
Dibsville- Abyss Dweller
- Posts : 9377
Reputation : 134
Join date : 2013-03-09
Age : 26
Location : Gensōkyō
You proposed a paradox too.Serious_Much wrote:Dibsville wrote:But God would have the power to make it stay as a boulder, being the all-powerful being that he is.
There's a reason god called everything different names- so we could differentiate things
By all means he could have created everything and called it all 'boulder'. But he didn't, and hence, a boulder is just a boulder
What you're proposing is a paradox there
|
|
|
